NEGAbriefLocal records made useful
Historical recordDemorestarchived · approved

Demorest approved a $148,945 utility-controls upgrade, but its progress remains unknown

Council chose the higher of two SCADA quotes and planned to use ARPA funds; the documented record does not show a contract, payment or completed installation.

By NEGA Brief Newsroom

At a glance

What this means now

Where it stands

Council approval is a completed act: it accepted J.K. Duren’s $148,945 quote. But approval of a quote is not, by itself, confirmation that the city paid that amount, signed a later contract, installed the upgrade, tested it or put it into operation. The cited minutes do not resolve whether work began, was completed or is operating.

The story

Demorest City Council unanimously approved a $148,945 quote from J.K. Duren for a SCADA-system upgrade on Sept. 3, 2024, selecting the utility-controls proposal after considering a lower-priced alternative. The 4-0 vote is the latest documented council action on the project, while its subsequent progress remains unclear.

SourcesCity Council Minutes — 9.3.24 CC RS Minutes SIGNED.pdf

The decision directs a significant public expenditure toward the system used in city utilities operations. SCADA—short for supervisory control and data acquisition—is the system council chose to upgrade, making the vote more consequential than a routine equipment purchase: it set the city’s chosen path for work on a utility-related control system and identified federal pandemic-relief money as the planned funding source.

SourcesCity Council Minutes — 9.3.24 WS Minutes SIGNED.pdfCity Council Minutes — 9.3.24 CC RS Minutes SIGNED.pdf

Earlier that same day, officials reviewed two prices for the upgrade: one for $133,000 and J.K. Duren’s $148,945 quote. Staff recommended the higher proposal, saying it would be funded with ARPA money. That recommendation carried into the regular council meeting, where members formally accepted the J.K. Duren quote by unanimous vote.

SourcesCity Council Minutes — 9.3.24 WS Minutes SIGNED.pdfCity Council Minutes — 9.3.24 CC RS Minutes SIGNED.pdf

City staff backed the $148,945 option rather than the $133,000 quote during the work-session discussion. The council then adopted that recommendation, with four members voting in favor and none opposed in the recorded vote. The work-session discussion also noted that the recommended quote excluded a possible Toccoa addition, leaving that potential addition outside the approved proposal as described in the minutes.

SourcesCity Council Minutes — 9.3.24 WS Minutes SIGNED.pdfCity Council Minutes — 9.3.24 CC RS Minutes SIGNED.pdf

Council approval is a completed act: it accepted J.K. Duren’s $148,945 quote. But approval of a quote is not, by itself, confirmation that the city paid that amount, signed a later contract, installed the upgrade, tested it or put it into operation. The cited minutes do not resolve whether work began, was completed or is operating.

SourcesCity Council Minutes — 9.3.24 CC RS Minutes SIGNED.pdf

The next concrete public milestone would be city documentation linking the approved proposal to a contract, payment, installation report or completion update. Until such a record appears, residents cannot determine from the documented council action when the work was scheduled, whether it proceeded under the approved quote, whether the cost changed, or whether the upgraded SCADA system entered service.

SourcesCity Council Minutes — 9.3.24 WS Minutes SIGNED.pdfCity Council Minutes — 9.3.24 CC RS Minutes SIGNED.pdf

Arguments in the record

Positions presented publicly

City staff and council

Staff recommended the $148,945 proposal, and the council unanimously approved it.

Implementation record

The cited minutes establish the approval but do not document a later contract, payment, installation, testing result or completion date.

What happened

How this issue got here

Open any step for its supporting record. A proposal remains labeled as proposed until later evidence establishes an outcome.

Discussed
discussed

Council reviewed SCADA upgrade quotes

Officials reviewed $133,000 and $148,945 SCADA upgrade quotes. Staff recommended the $148,945 option, to be funded with ARPA money; the quote excluded a possible Toccoa addition.

Approved
confirmed

Council approved $148,945 SCADA upgrade quote

The council unanimously approved, 4-0, a motion to accept J.K. Duren’s $148,945 quote for the SCADA system.

Still unresolved

What is not yet known

These are evidence gaps, not assumptions. They remain open until a dependable source closes them.

  1. The council record confirms approval of the quote but does not say whether work began, was completed, or is operating.

Research the record

Search the underlying agendas, minutes, and documents.

Search supporting records